Boulder Creek on the Okanogan National Forest
Case study of a weed management action gone wrong
This web page follows a series of letters to various government agencies
as a case study of a noxious weed management action--Boulder Creek on the
Okanogan National Forest--and what went wrong with plans. Preferred and
recommended actions available to managers were ignored, in preference for
more harmful actions, which impacted treated areas beyond acceptable limits.
Start here to follow the trail of information relating to the 1999 chemical
applications along Boulder Creek on the Okanogan National Forest.
-
Flawed Biological Evaluation by Okanogan
National Forest (July 12, 1999).
-
Letter requesting a review of problems caused by
improper herbicide use (Aug 25, 1999).
-
Field survey of herbicide damage to Boulder Creek (Sept 23, 1999).
-
First label violation. Letter notifying Forest Service of contractor violations of the herbicide label (230K PDF file, letter of January 28, 2000).
-
Second letter notifying responsible
agencies of the problem, their responsibilities, and suggesting a resolution (Februray 22, 2000).
-
(85K PDF)Second letter of August 3, 2000, repeating the request for assistance which was denied by the Forest Service, and initiating a second WSDA investigation into a new label violation.
-
(85K PDF)Second label violation by Forest Service contractor. Letter to WSDA.
-
Forest Service documentation ignored during the 1999 weed
treatment on the Okanogan NF, sent as quotations attached to the February
22, 2000 letter.
Selected photographs illustrating the type of damage
involved, but omitted from the EA and BE (click to enlarge, then click
the BACK button to return here after viewing):
Chemicals were broadcast sprayed into weed-free riparian areas |
Trees providing shade and cover were killed |
Native plants were killed, weakening road stability |
Noxious weeds survived next to killed native plants |
Erosion and sedimentation was increased in this at-risk stream |
Spraying was done directly into T&E fish habitat |